Saturday, July 28, 2012

Chemchem inapotoka karibu na Machinjioni

This right here is Hip Hop at its finest. Tanzania's own @Wakazi dropping verses over Mobb Deep's Hell on Earth instrumental. There are very few MCs with this impeccable delivery, and mastery of both languages.

Enjoy.


Monday, July 23, 2012

In Vino Veritas!

This video has inspired me to write a piece on education in Tanzania.

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

The Man in the Glass

When you get what you want in your struggle for self
And the world makes you king for a day
Just go to the mirror and look at yourself
And see what that man has to say.

For it isn’t your father, or mother, or wife
Whose judgment upon you must pass
The fellow whose verdict counts most in your life
Is the one staring back from the glass.

He’s the fellow to please – never mind all the rest
For he’s with you, clear to the end
And you’ve passed your most difficult, dangerous test
If the man in the glass is your friend.

You may fool the whole world down the pathway of years
And get pats on the back as you pass
But your final reward will be heartache and tears
If you’ve cheated the man in the glass.


This poem by Dale Wimbrow was published in 1934. Its relevance is timeless.

Monday, June 11, 2012

Telecoms sector needs to do more...

This article that I wrote was published in the Sunday Guardian of June 3rd.


I did nothing wrong as deputy minister to instruct TCRA

I read with particular interest an article published in the May 25 edition of this newspaper titled ‘Collective responsibility and emerging anarchy in state policy’ by Ani Jozeni. The article would not have warranted a response if it were not so elegantly written, so blatantly misleading and wrong on both facts and logic.

I am taking the liberty to respond so as to correct certain factual errors and flaws in logic, and offer him and the readers a bit of understanding about the telecoms sector.

Jozeni’s gripe is twofold: one, that it was incorrect for a government leader to ask Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority (TCRA) to take up with mobile phone operators an issue about poor mobile phone services and that we, who do not reside at the Treasury, must not complain about poor tax revenue collection from telecoms companies.  Two, that a deputy minister should not be talking about these things because of his imagined possibility that the minister may be having different thoughts.

You only need to possess a mobile phone to know that the quality of service – the rate of dropped calls, failure to initiate calls, unsolicited SMS, customer service issues and so forth – has been a source of complaints by many subscribers. There are specific regulations in the TCRA Act to do with the quality of services offered and the parameters to be adhered to by the operators are clearly stipulated.

It is absolutely the right thing to ask TCRA, which, by the way, is doing a fantastic job, to ensure that mobile phone operators are within these parameters because TCRA is ultimately responsible for the enforcement of the Act and its regulations.

You only need to be moderately informed about public affairs to know that low tax revenue collection from mobile phone companies has been an issue of debate in the National Assembly and by the general public. 

Now, what do the numbers say? In 2010, mobile phone companies grossed about US$ 1 billion, and paid corporate taxes amounting to US$1.7 million, according to a brief provided to me by TCRA during my visit to their office. During the same year, taxes paid by mobile phone operators in Kenya amounted to US$78.3 million, Uganda US$31.3 million and Rwanda US$14 million.

Surely, you could argue that Kenya’s economy is bigger than ours, but Rwanda, a much smaller economy compared to ours and with two major mobile phone service operators, collected taxes from the companies close to tenfold than we did – with our six main mobile phone service operators.

To be sure, no one is suggesting that mobile phone service operators broke tax laws here.  But anyone with the right mind will see that we could do far better than we are doing, and stating this, as I am doing now, is really stating the obvious. Effective taxation is done through timely and effective collection of information on businesses. Asking the responsible authorities to ensure that we do just that is the right thing to do.

To put the facts correctly, the two-week period reportedly issued by the deputy minister was for mobile phone operators to detail their plans to deal with their customers’ complaints about the quality of service, not to sort out tax issues. Still, Jozeni’s idea that we can’t talk about taxes now simply because the parliamentary budget session is less than a month away is being shortsighted.

Firstly, the country has a future beyond budget sessions, and, secondly, revenue measures can be adjusted even on the morning of budget day. Also his notion that only the Treasury – and not any other government ministry – should be concerned with government revenue is simply ridiculous.

TPDC, a regulator of upstream oil and gas activities, in undertaking its duties, including the auditing of production sharing agreements (PSA) with oil and gas companies, helps TRA collect a deserved amount of taxes. I could go on about how cooperation by different government entities is not only important but necessary in ensuring the right revenue measures are taken with a view to effective tax collection.

TCRA early in May announced a tender to procure, install and operate a mobile phone traffic monitoring system (TMS) which, among many other good things, will help us determine, and indeed track, the amount of minutes dialed and the SMS volume and therefore independently (yes, by ourselves) verify the amount of government revenue that could be due from the mobile phone companies.

This is where the nexus between the TCRA initiative and government revenue is found, a connection that Jozeni missed because, in his line of thinking, all initiatives relating to government revenue “start and are concluded at the Ministry of Finance”.

Last year, mobile phone operators reported that a total of about 20 billion minutes were dialed. We have no reason to believe that the operators lied about this number, but would it not be nice if the government, through TCRA, could verify the number on its own without relying on reports by the operators?

In 2010, Ghana’s TCRA deployed a more or less similar tracking technology to monitor just international calls traffic in and out of Ghana, and, within a year, in 2011, Ghana’s TRA increased its revenue collection from telecom operators by US$40 million, which was over and above what they were collecting before.

It is important to point out here that the culprits causing government loss in revenue include unscrupulous private individuals who do ‘SIM-boxing’ – that is, routing international calls and terminating them to a simple device set up in their homes and then connecting them here locally using local numbers. That’s the reason you sometimes receive an international call with a local number on your caller ID, thus depriving revenue to both telecom companies and the government.

Therefore, it can’t be so disastrous, as Jozeni would want us to believe, for a government leader, be it a minister, deputy minister or PS, to call for measures against this and other malpractices.

Obviously, the contribution of the telecoms industry to the country’s economy goes beyond taxes. I need not list here all the benefits accruing from telecoms sector investments in the country as they are obvious. But the fact remains that the sector could contribute far more than it is doing now. And one of our tasks at the ministry is to ensure that it does.

At the moment the telecoms sector’s contribution to the country’s GDP stands at a paltry 2.5 per cent. However, in Kenya, its contribution is 9 per cent while in Uganda it is 5.2 per cent. The 2.5 per cent contribution is at a glaring variance with the scale and pace of the sector’s growth.

Last year, the sector grew by about 22 per cent.  Thus far, it is the fastest growing sector and the growth has been steady for the past 10 years. Between 2001 and 2010 it grew at an average of 11 per cent per year while the GDP grew at an average of 7 per cent.

Total cumulative investment in the sector during the same period amounted to Shs. 2,563 billion. On average, telecom companies invested about Shs. 256 billion per year. Also, the mobile penetration rate increased by 53 per cent per year (on compounded annual growth rate) from the year 2001 to 2010. With this rate of increase in penetration, telecoms economists suggest that the industry’s contribution to the GDP should have been at least 5.3 per cent, not 2.5 per cent!

With these numbers I would like to tip off Jozeni to expect us who are charged with the development of the sector to continue talking about and working for more government revenue from the sector and for its increased contribution to the economy. I communicated this message to TCRA and the mobile phone operators that I visited recently. The encouraging thing is that almost all the operators I visited were committed to ensuring that the sector contributes more, and their future plans indicate this commitment. 

While the issues of telecoms taxes and contribution to GDP are important, it will be unfortunate if the discussion on role of the telecoms sector to the economy and improvement of people's lives remains solely on these matters. A lot has been done in the sector over the past 10 years, including an increase in financial services inclusion facilitated by Mobile Money. Just last year alone, mobile money services grew by 293 percent. An average distance to a bank is 50 kilometers, but thanks to the explosion of telecoms Mobile Money services, Tanzanians can find money transfer and other financial services within one kilometer.

The debate we should be having is whether this Mobile Money financial intermediation catalyses economic growth or is it just sheer money circulation with little impact on promoting consumption in the real economy or in fact contribution to savings and investments that spur wealth creation? Is the current regulation on mobile money sufficient to deal with issues of fraud, money laundering and customer protection?

Another discussion I am keen to have is what is the best model to get telecoms services access to areas that don't have access - areas that are deemed "commercially not viable" by telecoms operators, so that geography, settlement patterns and income levels do not deprive some of our people the benefits of telecoms services.

Also, of the Shs 1.6 trillion revenue grossed by telecoms operators in 2011, Shs 1.3 trillion came through voice services. Now that we have fibre optic network in most of the country, how do we move the sector to the next level, beyond the dominance of voice services, to the applications of more and sophisticated IT services and products? How do we create a critical mass of ICT entrepreneurs and hubs of innovations to create ICT solutions to our development and governance challenges? These questions, beyond telecoms revenue, occupy us in the Ministry and in associated institutions such Costech.

I talked about all these issues during the past weeks. Policy criticism – and indeed ideas – on these matters by Jozeni would have been heartening.

Jozeni also seems to be obsessed with titles: minister and deputy minister, and who can say or do what. This is a trivial matter, given the momentous task ahead of us to fix challenges in the telecoms sector. Everyone in government speaks on and executes government policy. In his article, he fails to point out where and which government policy was contravened.

He also fails to point out where the minister and deputy minister have contradicted each other. He eventually settles on the hypothetical “suppose the minister doesn't countersign the deputy minister’s directive…”. Well, on the flip side, suppose, as is the case now, the minister and the deputy minister speak the same language? Then his whole argument collapses, as it surely does.

Sure, the government has had its fair share of challenges in coordination and public communication, but Jozeni’s article misfired as a hit-piece on me and on this challenge.

As far as leadership style is concerned, Jozeni suggests that former prime minister, the late Edward Moringe Sokoine, the Member of Parliament for Vunjo, Mr. Augustine Lyatonga Mrema and myself are cut from the same cloth. If one entertains the idea that Mrema’s name here is misplaced, I would be flattered. -----------

--------   January Makamba is a Member of Parliament for Bumbuli, and Deputy Minister for Communications, Science and Technology.  

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

A Critique of a Tanzania People

Humanity has always been advancing; even during hard times humans constantly find ways to manipulate their environment and innovate new technologies to guarantee their immediate survival on this planet. However, the realization of human progress as a specie have been uneven. This is obvious. Inequality across the countries and across individuals have been demonstrated for decades. But humanity have always been stratified, there were no egalitarian era recorded in our history. So the pursuit of equality is impractical. I am not suggesting a complete alienation from The Commons. I am merely pointing out the obvious, and provide clarity in this important subject. The process of wealth creation is the only solution to decrease rampant inequality. Inequality will be decreased not by distributing the existing wealth, but by the poor creating their own wealth. I will explain.

With this backdrop, it is important to understand that individual wealth creation has never been achieved by sets of legislations alone. Self determination and strong work ethics have complimented societal laws to guide the creation of populous middle class. You see, the construction of a strong middle class is a generational process. And it involves enormous sacrifices from the parents by heavily investing in their children. An average American parents spend up to $38,000 per child by the time the child reach 34 years old.  In doing so, they are guaranteeing a healthier and educated offspring-- a skilled job, hence higher purchasing power, and a lifetime taxpayer to the state. Rich countries had amassed wealth by conquering, and extracting free raw materials with free labor. But you should not overlook the role played by their citizens in taking advantage of resources provided by the states in improving their well-being. If you look at countries that have gotten wealthier, their citizens had played a bigger role in sacrificing and not expecting hand-outs.

This model of wealth creation is contrary to Tanzania's, and like-minded countries. The triumph of democracy has enabled the people to choose their leaders (rightly so). But it has also forced aspired leaders to be willing to say anything to be elected. Gone were the days of "tujifunge mkanda"; older generations of leaders used to call on Tanzania people to work hard to betterment their children's lives. The new age of politicians will promise anything for a vote. Re-distribution of land, free education, free healthcare, and even daring to cheat the markets. Voters desires have become entitlements, and are made to believe that the responsibilities for creation of their personal wealth is government's. Even country's conversation has turned populistic and simplistic. Intellectuals and politicians spend their days discussing about sitting allowances, and percentage of Muslims and Christians on constitution committee.

We should be worried when voters have unrealistic expectations from the government, which are shaped by politicians' rhetoric. The truth is no government interventions will influence citizen's capabilities. Free education will not educate your offsprings if you are a bad parent. Capabilities are built by self determination. Tanzanians have to start looking at ourselves, our attitude, work ethics, and our values if we wish to truly decrease the inequality gap. And start looking for a leader who will tell you that, having gold buried hundreds of feet underground doesn't mean a sh!t until it is in the jewelry store.

I will end with this. We are the most populous country in East Africa which has a net negative remittance. That is we send more money to our relatives abroad than they send back home.

Thuwein

Friday, March 16, 2012

Letter to My Fathers

Letter to My Fathers
(read at PEN & MIC event on 6 February 2011)

Because you have not been listening to me, I have decided to write to you – so that my children’s grandchildren may know that you are I were made of different cloths.

I have a lot of bones to pick with you. But the bottom line is this: you have failed to realize the mission of your generation, you have failed to inspire my peers to greatness, and now you want to drag me into the schizophrenia, the insecurities, and the dwarfed ambition of your generation.

I do not understand why you have not managed to be as selfless as your father, who continues to inspire me even though I haven’t met him.

I am disappointed not because you have not set the conditions for my kids to be astronauts, but because your greed, your narcissism, your hypocrisy are setting the conditions for me to be cynical – and therefore underachieve.

I do not expect you to build a Space program. But the least you can do is hand the country over to us in one piece. We will take it from there.

But for that to happen, I am going to have to say ENOUGH. So, I write today to tell you ENOUGH.

ENOUGH with your obsession with being vindicated at all cost – you embarrass us by insulting each other in newspapers each morning.

ENOUGH with extreme verbal rhetoric and fire and brimstone in explaining your differences with your peers – you remove the possibility of compromise; you corrode the hearts of those of us obsessed with reason.
ENOUGH with licking the boots of those owning the media – you bestow legitimacy to shadowy figures of questionable moral rectitude.

ENOUGH with your daily proclamations that you are clean, you are for justice – while we know that what you own and what you have could not have come from your income, that you took a concubine, that on a trip to China, you flew first class and drank whisky more expensive than mathematical sets of the entire school.

ENOUGH with your habit of theatrically and hypocritically hugging and laughing with a person we all know you detest. We don’t understand it.

ENOUGH with your reliance on the false crutches of witchcraft to ostensibly brighten your face, sweeten your tongue, and neuter your adversaries.

ENOUGH with pleading and waiting for Santa Claus to come and fill your coffers so that you can pay my teachers and buy my textbooks.

Of course, we see some things that you have done: more roads, more clinics, more skyscrapers, bigger budget, bigger parliament, free and frenzied media. But then these are managerial stuff. What about the stuff of leadership: Community. Society. Arts. Culture. Truth.

ENOUGH with everything: with your love for ambiguity; with your distaste with clarity.

Before I go, I want you to help me with few things:

Why did you get Tanzania to be called an experiment?

• Your embraced multipartism at one point, you dropped it, and adopted it again.

• You embraced capitalism at one point, you dropped it, and adopted it again.

• You change curriculum everyday – at one point you dropped history and geography – the essence of self-knowledge and knowledge about the world. You even dropped chemistry and physics – the essence of conquering the frontiers of the unknown universe. Then, you reinstated them.

• You started the East African Community – at great cost. Then you killed it – at greater cost. Then you restarted it – even without really being sure that you want to be in it.

• You waited until 2004 to build secondary schools in all corners of Tanzania. Seriously, where were you all these years? A generation of my peers BEFORE these new schools could not earn a living with their secondary education. A generation of my peers AFTER these schools can’t earn a living with this education.

Perhaps it is not your fault. I know you have had to contend with the harsh realities of your era – in which you were denied of as simple pleasures as a television broadcast. Perhaps the shoes you have had to fill were too big for you – and the might and the sacrifices of the pre-independence generation dwarfed you, and made sterile your art of possibility.

So, time is now for us to run the show. In fact, we already run stuff. Back in the days, you were the most high-tech person in the house – when the cassette player was the most high tech gadget in the house. Today, when gadgets are more complicated, you call on us to “configure”. This means we are wired for this complex world than you can appreciate. We run a lot of stuff around town. We make stuff work – at the banks, at the malls, in server rooms. We design, we create, we execute: from banners to ringtones. We tweet - and I may need to explain this: that is, with our fingertips, we talk to the world. Surely, we can steer our country forward.

Of course, we are not perfect. Just as you, we are prone to intellectual laziness. Some of us are tempted to live beyond our means. And, for some of us, something that is not “fasta” – including a university degree – is not good enough. But, despite this, we are good enough to create the future we want. And time is now.

I have to go. In the meantime, if you ask me what exactly do I want, I will tell you this: I want stuff to work. Full stop. We care less about your tantrums that you were right yesterday and your certain peer was wrong; that you are for truth and justice and your certain colleague is not; that you killed the lion with your bare hands – and there are no more heroes these days; and that, me and my peers, are impatient and undisciplined, and that we are embodiment of moral decay. Maybe. And, if so, we learnt from the best. Still, hand over the country to us in one piece. It is not too much to ask.

Thank you,

January

February 6th, 2011

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Engaging Bumbuli Constituents....

So, when I ran for MP I decided that I should engage my constituents as much and as often as possible. One of the ways I decided to use was SMS as lots of people, even in rural areas, have mobile phones. But I figured that most of my people will be constrained - and the excercise will not be effective - if they have to pay to send SMS to me. So, I decided to make it a free service. That people in Bumbuli send free messages when they want to contact me. But, somebody has to pay for it. And that is me. I applied for a short-code with TCRA for these 1500... numbers. Then negotiated with mobile phone companies for at-cost SMS rate. I then distributed the number - through posters and in public meetings - for my people to send messages if they have ANY matter - advice, complaint, etc - that they want to bring to my attention. The messages go into a web platform, and every morning and afternoon, my Assistant Alex and I log-in to see what Bumbuli people are saying. When I'm travelling Alex emails me the day's messages. We respond to some, take action on others, and also forward others to responsible authorities in the District, example DC, DED, OCD, etc. The program has been running for almost a year now and has been wildly successful. I know more about issues on the ground - even when I'm in New York - than officials on the ground. In terms of cost, it is actually cheaper than one would think. Initially, it was expensive as we were getting a lot of messages, most of them saying things like "Mheshimiwa, kumekucha, umeamkaje?". With public education, we cut down on those.

In the system, we can segment messages on issues, areas (kata), etc. On March 6th, I was in Vuga, and Alex, from my office in Dar, emailed me Vuga SMSes so that I can address the issues while there. Here I provide some. And this is just Vuga, we have so many messages from many different places.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

On Tuesday, March 6, 2012, alex manonga <....@bumbuli.org> wrote:
> Nimeambiwa leo utakuwa Vuga, hizi ni baadhi ya kero ambazo zimekuwa zikijirudia na huenda zikajitokeza. Nimekutumia ili uwe na picha halisi kabla ya kuzungumza na wananchi, mipira tayari Hozza alimkabidhi Diwani kwa baadhi ya teams. Nitakuwa nafoward kwa viongozi zile message ambazo hazihitaji privacy protection kama hiyo ya mwisho inayomtaja Diwani. Baga nitakutumia baadaye.

> 2.56E+11 Nashukuru sana mbunge kwa sms yako kwasasa nipo kilimanjaro kwa wazaz mwl wa vuga.
> 2.56E+11 Haruna shemhina kijiji cha kidundai  kata vuga maoni ni kuhusu baraba yetu  ya kutoka bangala kidundai kila mwaka tunapewa ahadi lakini hakuna kinachofanyika nakuomba  ndugu m h mbunge hili swala liingilie kati
> 2.56E+11 Ruzuku mpaka mwezi gani katika kij chetu kiungo chakuunga bomba maji yawafikie watu pesa tungeitumia sasa m kiti kishewa vuga
> 2.56E+11 SISI NIVIJANA WAKIJIJI CHA BAGHAI KATA YA VUGA KELO YETU NI KWAMBA UWANJA TUNAO LAKINI VIFAA VYA MICHEZO HATUNA KAMA MIPIRA NA JEZI MIMI NI RAMADHANI MDOE
> 2.56E+11 JANUAR .MAKAMBA .MBONA .HATUJAPATA .MAJIBU .MAZURI .KUHUSU .UMEME .IDD .BAKARI .VUGA .LUSHOTO
> 2.56E+11 Bashiru Ally .katib u wa c.c.m tawi la Kidundai kata xa  vuga jimbo la Bum buli Mhe mbunge  ni lini kero mama ya Barabara kidu ndai itatuishia?
> 2.56E+11 MH.me ni mwl wa s/m vuga napenda sana mazingira ya vuga lushoto lakn fedha yng haitosh pamoja na kulipia kodi TUNAOMBA UJENZ WA NYUMBA ZA WALIMU ahsante
> 2.56E+11 MHESHIMIWA .JANUARY .MAKAMBA .PIGANIA .VUGA .TUPATE .UMEME .NAMAJI .UKIZINTIA .VUGA .UMEPITABILAKUPINGWAJ .MIMI .IDD .BAKAR
> 2.56E+11 ROBERT KARATA,VUGA KIHITU MAULWI. KELOYETU MAJI SAFI NA SALAMA YA BOMBA WAMAMA WANAPATA SHIDA YAMAJI
> 2.56E+11 Kero yangu kwako Mh.Mbunge ni tatizo la maji katika eneo lako la Kata ya Vuga maji ya kisima yanapatikana kwa siku ya Ijumaa tu .Na ina kuwa tatizo kubwa kwa sisi wafanyakazi kufanya kazi katika mazingila magumu kiasi hiki.Itafika mahali ukose wafany
> 2.56E+11 Tunakupongeza kwa juhudi zako ktk Jimbo letu la Bumbuli.Tunaomba swala la umeme kata ya vuga,uliwekee kipaombele kwani tumeona Tanesco wamekuja kupima,tunaomba wasiishie kupima tu.mungu akupe maisha marefu na afya njema Mbunge wetu.Ni mimi mwl.MAHONG
> 2.56E+11 Mimi mwl wa shule ya msingi kata ya vuga MH.MBUNGE KAZ YANG NAIPENDA SANA LAKIN KUTOKANA NA KUKOSA UMEME,NYUMBA ZA WALIMU,PAMOJA NA BARABARA KUNANIFANYA NICHUKIE KAZI YANGU TUSAIDIE MBUNGE
> 2.56E+11 MH.MBUNGE mimi ni mwl wa shule ya msing vuga tunaomba tujengewe nyumba za walimu kwan kulipa kodi hatuwez kwan mshahara nimdogo na majukum ni mengi
> 2.56E+11 SHULE ZA KATA YA VUGA NI NNE  UMEME HAKUNA NA TUNAHITAJI MAABARA SASA UNATUAHIDI NINI.MIMI BAKARY.H.KIBANGA.KATA VUGA.KIJIJI BAGHAI.
> 2.56E+11 Asalamu Akeykum Ndugu mbunge napenda kukupa pore sana. Tatizo letu vijana kataya vuga kijiji cha Baghai ni michezo .Mipira kwetu ni haba pamoja na jezi
> 2.56E+11 Tunakushukuru,MH.MBUNGE kwa juhudi zako katika Jimbo letu,Bado kilio chetu cha umeme kata ya Vuga tunakusubiri utukamilishie.ni sisi wapiga kura wako kata ya Vuga.
>
> 2.56E+11 Kwakua Maji Niuhai Uharibifuunaofanyika Katikachanzo Chamaji Kihitu Katayavuga Inahitaji Kushughulikiwa Bilakuchelewa.
>
> 2.56E+11 Vuga Eneola Kihitu Limevamiwa Nawachimba Madini Katikachanzo Chamaji Yanayotumi Kwawananchi Tunaomba Msaada .
>
> 2.56E+11 Je utatusaidiaje ss tunaosoma sayansi ktk shule yetu wakati hatuna maabala na walimu wa sayansi?.Nimimi Hemedy toka Vuga Bazo sec school.
>
> 2.56E+11 Maji niuhai kwa binadamu ila sasa ktk kijiji chetu vyanzo vya maji vimeharibiwa na wachimba madini na inasemekana wana kojoa na hajakubwa pia.utatusaidiaje kunusuru afya zetu.Ni mimi Herasy toka Vuga Bazo.
> 2.56E+11 SAMA HANI MHSHIMIWA NAOMBA MSADA WAPESA YA BIASHALA ASHILNA HUSENI
>  VUGAKISHEWA,
> 2.56E+11 Mh salam alaykum wananchi wako wakitongoji cha mtimule bado ile kero yao ya maji imekua ina wasumbua sana  wanaijadili kila siku hawajapata ufumbuzi ni mimi M .A.Shembilu kijiji cha Baghai kata ya Vuga
>
> 2.56E+11 Mh,mbona vuga mikopo kwetu tabu sana tatizo nini tunaiyona kwa wenzetu.
>
> 2.56E+11 Mh.mbunge lijue tatito la shule ya Sekondari Vuga-Bazo.Kuna upungufu mkubwa wa walimu wazazi wa Vuga wanakuomba wewe mtetezi wao uwatatulie tatizo hilo kubwa.SALIMINA MAGOGO WA VUGA-KISHEWA.
>
> 2.56E+11 JINA KIBWANA H MBARUKU KIJIJI CHA KILUWAI KATA YA  VUGA KERO NI UKOSEFU WA MAJI  YA B6BA KATIKA KIJIJI HIKI CHA KILUWAI
> 2.56E+11 Je utatusaidiaje ss tunaosoma sayansi ktk shule yetu wakati hatuna maabala na walimu wa sayansi?.Nimimi Hemedy toka Vuga Bazo sec school.
>
> 2.56E+11 Mbona hatuoni ahadi ulizotuahidi vuga hata ofisi ulioahi kwa ajili kukuona tabu.
>
> 2.56E+11 Ahsantesana  MH.JANUARY MAKAMBA kwakutupatiamipiraborakabisa vijanawavuga kwakwelitumefurahi kwakuona MBUNGE wetu unajalimichezo nakutakiakazinjema nauzidikutukumbuka nimimi HASSANI ISSA timu yaKIHITU
> 2.56E+11
> MIMI NAITWA JUMAA DHAHABU NATOKA KATA YA VUGA.. USHAURI WANGU KWA MH MBUNGE WA BUMBULI. UWE NA OFISI YA MBUNGE KILA KATA KWA AJILI YA KUSHUGHULIKIA MAMBO YA WANANCHI KUPITIA OFI YA MBUNGE. 2. UWE NA MFUKO WA MBUNGE UTAKAO SAIDIA KATIKA ELIMU KWA VIJA
>
> 2.56E+11 Kamua baba hivyo hivo Afled vuga
>
> 2.56E+11 Sasa BABA UMEME VUGA VIPI ALFLED
>
> 2.56E+11 Tunahitaji vifaa vyamichezo kama vile viatu&mipira ilikuendeleza vipaji vuga.Heras toka vuga bazo.
>
> 2.56E+11 MIMI MWL S.MHAGAMA WA KATA YA VUGA.MH.VUGA NIGIZA TUPU WEKAHISTORIA KWAKUTULETEA UMEME NAKUAMINI KWASABABU UNAUCHUNGU NAJIMBO. AHASANTE
> 2.56E+11 HAKUNA WALIMU WA SAYANSI SEKONDARI VUGA  BAZO  . SAMWEL  KATA  VUGA  VUGA
>
> 2.56E+11 Naitwa  Daudi  Taratibu nipo katika kijiji cha kiluwai kata  ya vuga kero yetu ni maji ya bomba ambaYO TULIAHIDIWA KUYAPATA  NA MIMEA YETU ILIKATWA BILA MALIPO TUKARIDHIKA TUKAAHIDIWA KUWA TANGI LA MAJI  LITAJENGWA KATIKA  KITONGOJI CHA MANKOLE KITON
>
> 2.56E+11 Naitwa  Daudi  Taratibu nipo katika kijiji cha kiluwai kata  ya vuga kero yetu ni maji ya bomba ambaYO TULIAHIDIWA KUYAPATA  NA MIMEA YETU ILIKATWA BILA MALIPO TUKARIDHIKA TUKAAHIDIWA KUWA TANGI LA MAJI  LITAJENGWA KATIKA  KITONGOJI CHA MANKOLE KITON
>
> 2.56E+11 NAKUSHURU MI BINAFSI PAMOJA NA JOPO LANGU LA WALIMU KATA VUGA KWA JITIHADA ZAKO ZA KUTUBADILISHA KIMAISHA NA KUTUPA MAENDELEO  YA UHAKIKA KWA KUTULETEA UMEME, BARABARA YA BANGALA KIDUNDAI,NAAMINI MENGINE KAMA HOSTEL BAZO SEK.ZAHANATI VUGA NA KUINUA K
> 2.56E+11 MIMI NAITWA JUMAA DHAHABU. KATA YA VUGA. KERO MHESHIMIWA DIWANI WETU AMEKUWA MPIGA VITA WA MAENDELEO AMEKUWA ANAPINGA ASASI ZA KIRAIA NAKUDAI KUWA MBUNGE ANAZIKATAA HAINGII AKILINI KWANI TUNATAMBUA KUWA HUU NI UZUSHI WA DIWAANI
>
>
>
>

Friday, February 10, 2012

My Private Member's Motion on Rental Housing Act in Parliament 10 February 2012

HOJA BINAFSI YA NDUGU JANUARY MAKAMBA (CCM – BUMBULI) KUHUSU SHERIA YA UDHIBITI WA SHUGHULI ZA UPANGAJI NYUMBA ZA MAKAZI (RENTAL HOUSING ACT)
9 Februari, 2012
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Nakushukuru kwa kunipa fursa na heshima ya kuwasilisha hoja hii katika Bunge lako tukufu.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Hoja yangu ina madhumuni ya kuliomba Bunge lako tukufu liazimie, kwa kauli moja, kuitaka Serikali, katika Mkutano ujao wa Saba wa Bunge, kuleta Muswada wa Sheria ya Kudhibiti Upangaji wa Nyumba za Makazi (Rental Housing Act):
1. Itakayoweka utaratibu na udhibiti wa sekta ya upangaji wa nyumba nchini kwa ujumla;
 
2. Itakayowezesha kuanzishwa kwa Wakala wa Udhibiti wa Sekta ya Nyumba – Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA).
 
3. Itakayoainisha wazi haki na wajibu wa wapangaji na wenye nyumba;
 
4. Itakayoweka utaratibu wa haraka na rahisi zaidi kwa wapangaji na wenye nyumba kupata haki zao;
 
5. Itakayodhibiti na kuweka adhabu kwa vitendo vya unyanyasaji dhidi ya wapangaji;
 
6. Itakayoweka utaratibu wa ukaguzi wa viwango na hali za makazi ya kupanga;
 
7. Itakayozuia na kuweka adhabu kwa utaratibu wa kutoza kodi ya nyumba kwa miezi sita au mwaka mzima;
 
8. Itakayodhibiti wenye nyumba kuwalazimisha wapangaji kulipa kodi ya nyumba kwa fedha za kigeni, hasa dola za kimarekani;
 
9. Itakayodhibiti upandishaji holela wa kodi za nyumba;
 
10. Itakayowezesha mikataba ya upangaji wa nyumba kusajiliwa;
 
11. Itakayoweka utaratibu wa kuwatambua na kuwasajili madalali wa nyumba ili kudhibiti vitendo vyao.
 
12. Itakayoiwezesha Serikali kupata mapato kutokana na biashara ya upangaji nyumba kwa kuwalazimisha wenye nyumba kujisajili kwenye Mamlaka husika na kutoa risiti kwa wapangaji;
 
13. Itakayoweka taratibu nyingine mbalimbali zitakazolinda haki za wapangaji na wenye nyumba na zitakazowezesha sekta ya makazi kukua na kushamiri na kupunguza tatizo la makazi nchini.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Msingi wa hoja hii ni malalamiko mengi ambayo mimi na ninyi viongozi wenzangu mmekuwa mkiyapata kutoka wananchi wengi hasa waishio mijini kutokana na adha wanazopata katika kutafuta nyumba za kupanga au kuishi kwenye nyumba za kupanga.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Naomba uniruhusu nitoe mifano hai ya baadhi ya watu walionifuata na kunielezea masaibu yao.
Dora, ni binti wa miaka 30, ni mwandishi wa habari. Alipomaliza Chuo Kikuu alibahatika kupata kazi kwenye gazeti moja pale Dar es Salaam. Kwa kuwa alipata kazi, na kwa kuwa wazazi wake hawakai Dar es Salaam, aliamua kutafuta chumba cha kupanga ili aanze maisha yake. Alihangaika kwa miezi nane bila kupata nyumba. Kila alipoenda, kwanza aliambiwa lazima awe na fedha ya kodi ya miezi sita na sehemu nyingine aliambiwa mwaka mzima. Hili lilikuwa gumu kwake kwasababu ndio alikuwa amepata kazi na anaanza maisha, pesa ya kodi kwa mwaka mzima hakuwa nayo.
 
Pili, sehemu nyingi wenye nyumba walimwambia kwamba hawakodishi nyumba kwa mtu ambaye hajaoa wala kuolewa. Kimsingi, hii sio haki. Lakini Dora hakuwa na pa kwenda.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Huko nyumba, ilikuwepo Sheria ya Udhibiti wa Pango ya Mwaka 1984 (Rental Restriction Act of 1984), ambayo ilikuwa inamlinda Dora asitozwe kodi ya mwaka. Hata hivyo, Sheria hiyo ilifutwa mwaka 2005 na baadhi ya vipengele kuingizwa kama marekebisho ya Sheria ya Ardhi ya mwaka 1999 na Sheria ya Mahakama ya Ardhi ya Mwaka 2005. Hata hivyo, vipengele madhubuti vya kumlinda mpangaji vilitupwa kabisa.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Yupo pia Bwana Saidi Bakari Shemweta, mzaliwa wa jimbo langu la Bumbuli anayeishi Mbagala. Ana familia ya watu wa sita: mke na watoto watatu na ndugu wengine wawili. Anafanya biashara ndogo ndogo na kipato chake ni cha siku kwa siku. Alikuwa na mkataba wa pango wa mwaka mzima. Lakini mkataba huo ulikuwa wa kuandikishiana kwenye kipande cha karatasi. Mkataba huo ulitengenezwa na mwenye nyumba na ulisheheni zaidi maslahi ya mwenye nyumba kuliko haki zake kama mpangaji. Alikuwa analipa kodi bila kupewa risiti. Na wapangaji wenzake nao wanalipa kodi bila risiti. Lakini yeye kwenye biashara zake, ambazo zina kipato kidogo kuliko cha mwenye nyumba, analipa kodi. Hali ya makazi anayoishi, kwa maana ya idadi vya watu kulinganisha na vyoo, hali ya upatikanaji maji, ilikuwa hailingani na kiwango cha kodi anayolipa. Na hata pale ambapo mwenye nyumba alipaswa kufanya matengenezo, hakuwa anafanya hivyo.
 
Pamoja na yote hayo, ghafla mwenye nyumba aliamua kupandisha kodi katikati ya mkataba kwa kuwa tu alipata mpangaji aliyekuwa tayari kulipa kodi kubwa kuliko Bwana Shemweta. Bwana Shemweta alitafutiwa kosa, akapewa notisi ya ghafla. Kwa kuwa hakuweza kupata nyumba ndani ya kipindi kifupi, kwa tatizo lilelile la kukosa kodi ya mwaka mzima, akalazimika kuondolewa kwa nguvu kwa vitu vyake kutolewa nje pamoja na watoto na ndugu zake. Hakujua pa kwenda kudai haki yake. Hakujua analindwa na Sheria gani na hakujua pa kuanzia.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Naamini masaibu kama haya ya Dora na Shemweta yapo mengi na mengine ukisikia yanasikitisha zaidi. Sisi Wabunge tumekuja hapa Bungeni kama wawakilishi wa watu ili tutunge Sheria kwa manufaa ya walio wengi. Lakini tupo hapa tukitambua kwamba jamii yetu ina matabaka. Ina wanyonge na ina wenye mabavu. Ina watu wanaokunywa mvinyo wa dola 2,000 kwa chupa, na ina watu ambao hawajui mchana watakula nini. Lakini wote hawa wanahitaji makazi. Lakini kuna waliojaliwa kujenga nyumba zao, ambao makazi sio jambo lililo katika mawazo yao, lakini kuna wengi zaidi ambao hawakujaliwa ambao makazi ndio shaka yao kubwa. Katika kutunga Sheria lazima tuendeshwe na msingi wa kusaidia wanyonge, pamoja na kwamba tunalinda haki za raia wote wa nchi yetu.  
 
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Mwaka 2005, Bunge lilifuta Sheria ya Udhibiti wa Pango ya Mwaka 1984 (Rental Restriction Act of 1984) ambayo ilikuwa inatoa ulinzi kwa wanyonge ambao ni wapangaji. Sababu ya kuifuta Sheria hii ilikuwa ni kwamba eti Sheria za kudhibiti bei ni sheria za enzi za kijamaa na kwamba pango liachwe liwe kazi ya soko. Huu sio ukweli. Sheria hii ilitungwa mwaka 1962 wakati nchi yetu ilikuwa bado haijaingia kwenye siasa ya ujamaa. Lakini pia nchi nyingi za kibepari zina Sheria ya Kudhibiti Pango, ikiwemo Kenya, ambapo chini ya Sheria yao Namba 296, ni kosa kudai pango la zaidi ya miezi miwili, na Uganda, chini ya Sheria yao Namba 231. Vilevile, katika mageuzi ya uchumi wa nchi yetu tumeunda taasisi nyingi na tumetunga Sheria kadhaa zinazodhibiti bei za bidhaa mbalimbali – mfano: SUMATRA, bei za usafiri; EWURA, bei ya nishati; TCRA, bei za kupiga simu.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Kama tumeona ni sahihi kuweka udhibiti kwamba makampuni ya simu za mikononi yasipandishe bei ya kupiga simu holela, kwanini tusiweke udhibiti kwenye hitaji muhimu la maisha ya mwanadamu, yaani makazi, kwamba mwenye nyumba asipandishe kodi holela, kwa kiwango na wakati wowote anaotaka?
 
Inawezekana kukawa na wasiwasi kwamba tukiweka udhibiti wa shughuli za pango, biashara ya upangishaji nyumba itaharibika na uwekezaji utazorota. Hiyo inawekana tu kama hakuna udhibiti wa Serikali. Ndio maana napendekeza kwamba katika Sheria ambayo Serikali basi kuanzishwe Mamlaka ya Udhibiti wa Biashara ya Nyumba (Real Estate Regulatory Agency – RERA) ambayo itadhibiti miendeno ya wadau wote katika sekta ya nyumba. Nchi nyingi zilizofanya vizuri katika sekta ya makazi zina mamlaka hizi.
 
Vilevile, tumeona kwamba, hata baada ya kuifuta Sheria ya Rental Restriction Act ya 1984, bado mahitaji ya nyumba yameongezeka na uwekezaji haujakidhi mahitaji.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Sheria ninayopendekeza itungwe sio ya kudhibiti bei ya pango pekee. Ni sheria ya kudhibiti mwenendo mzima wa biashara ya upangaji ili wadau na washiriki wote kwenye biashara hii – yaani wenye nyumba, wapangaji, madalali, Serikali – wapate haki zao za msingi, na mashauri na migogoro ya nyumba ipate kushughulikiwa kwa haraka, kwa haki na kwa ukamilifu.
 
Vilevile, ni muhimu nikaweka wazi kwamba Sheria ninayopendekeza sio Sheria ya kuwakandamiza wenye nyumba. Ni sheria itakayolinda maslahi ya wote, kwani ni dhahiri kabisa kwamba wapo wapangaji ambao nao hawatimizi wajibu wao na ambao ni wasumbufu katika kulipa pango na wazembe katika kutunza mali za wenye nyumba.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Ni dhahiri kwamba liko tatizo la nyumba na makazi nchini. Takwimu zinaonyesha kwamba kuna upungufu wa nyumba takriban milioni tatu nchini kwa sasa, na kwamba kila mwaka kunahitajika nyumba mpya 200,000. Kasi ya ujenzi wa nyumba haiendani na mahitaji haya licha ya uamuzi wetu wa kuweka uhuru mkubwa wa soko katika biashara hii. Lakini hatuwezi kukaa, kama Serikali na kama viongozi, na kukubali kwamba kwa kuwa kuna upungufu wa nyumba, na kwa kuwa soko la nyumba linawapa nguvu zaidi wenye nyumba, basi haki za wanyonge, ambao ni wapangaji, zisilindwe.  
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Inawezekana ikaja hoja kwamba Sheria ya Ardhi ya Mwaka 1999, na Sheria ya Mahakama ya Ardhi ya Mwaka 2005, zinatoa kinga kwa wapangaji. Baada ya utafiti wangu, na kwa msaada wa wataalamu wa Sheria zinazohusiana na makazi, ukweli ni kwamba Sheria hizo hazitoshelezi. Kwa mfano, kwa Sheria za sasa, mwenye nyumba hana haja ya kwenda mahakamani kupata haki yake ya kimkataba - anaweza kuuza kitu chochote cha mpangaji, lakini mpangaji, ili kupata haki yake, ni lazima aende mahakamani ambako kuna mlolongo mrefu.
 
Kwa kweli hatuna haja kufanya utafiti wa kina kubaini tatizo kwenye shughuli za upangaji, matatizo kwenye sekta ya upangaji tunayona kila siku na tunayajua. Inahitajika Sheria mpya, mahsusi kabisa kwa masuala ya makazi ili Sheria hizi mbili zibaki katika masuala ya ardhi ambayo nayo pia yana mambo mengi.
 
Naamini katika azma ya Serikali kuboresha hali ya makazi nchini. Naamini katika uongozi thabiti wa Waziri wa Ardhi, Nyumba na Maendeleo ya Makazi, Profesa Anna Tibaijuka, ambaye anafanya kazi nzuri. Naamini kabisa kwamba tukitunga Sheria hii na ikasimamiwa vizuri tutakuwa tumewasaidia Watanzania zaidi ya milioni 14 wanaoathirika na udhibiti mdogo katika shughuli za upangaji.
 
Naamini pia kwamba, katika mchakato wa kutunga Sheria hii, wadau wote watashirikishwa kutoa mawazo na maoni yao.
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
Kabla sijatoa hoja yenyewe napenda kuwashukuru viongozi wa Chama cha Wapangaji Tanzania walionisaidia na kunihimiza kuleta hoja hii. Nawashukuru pia waandishi wa habari walioandika habari na makala kuunga mkono kusudio la hoja hii. Nawashukuru marafiki zangu wote kwenye mitandao ya kijamii ya Twitter na Facebook kwa kunipa maoni na ushauri na kuunga mkono hoja hii. Nawashukuru wote, ikiwemo Wabunge walionipa moyo kuleta hoja hii.
 
Baada ya maelezo hayo, naomba sasa niwasilishe hoja yenyewe. Hoja hii inawasilishwa kwa mujibu wa Kanuni za  Kudumu za Bunge Toleo la 2007, Kanuni ya 54 (i).
 
Mheshimiwa Spika,
KWA KUWA, asilimia kubwa ya Watanzania, hasa waishio mijini, wanaishi kwenye nyumba za kupanga, na karibu asilimia 40 ya kipato chao wanakitumia kwa ajili ya kulipia pango;
 
KWA KUWA, kumekuwa na udhibiti mdogo wa biashara ya upangaji, na kupelekea kuongezeka kwa vitendo vya unyanyasaji dhidi ya wapangaji, ikiwemo kudaiwa pango la miezi sita hadi mwaka mzima, tena kwa fedha za kigeni;
 
KWA KUWA, kumekuwa na tatizo la makazi mijini na hivyo kuwalazimisha wapangaji kukubali masharti ya upangaji yanayoenda kinyume na haki, na kwa kuwa vitendo hivi vimekuwa vinaendelea kwa muda mrefu bila udhibiti;
 
KWA KUWA, hakuna Sheria mama inayodhibiti upangaji na inayolinda haki za mpangaji, na kwa kuwa Sheria ya Ardhi ya 1999 na Sheria ya Mahakama ya Ardhi ya 2005 hazitoa udhibiti kamilifu wa sekta ya upangaji nyumba,
​
HIVYO BASI, Bunge liazimie kuitaka Serikali, kwa haraka inavyowezekana, ilete Muswada wa Sheria ya Kudhibiti Shughuli za Upangaji wa Nyumba (Rental Housing Act) ambayo, pamoja na mambo mengine, itakaweka utaratibu na udhibiti wa sekta ya upangaji wa nyumba ikiwemo kuweka haki na wajibu wa wapangaji na wenye nyumba, kuweka mazingira ya ukuaji wa sekta ya makazi, na kuanzishwa kwa Mamlaka ya Udhibiti wa Sekta ya Nyumba (Real Estate Regulatory Authority).

Mheshimiwa Spika,

Naomba kutoa Hoja.

January Makamba
10 Februari 2012

Friday, December 30, 2011

I Tweet, Therefore I Am!

I Tweet, Therefore I am!

January Makamba - @JMakamba

All politicians have a common need: a friendly platform to communicate their ideas, to rationalize their actions, to defend themselves and, a favourite pastime, to attack each other.

Technology has made modern combat lethal, yet impersonal. Gone are the days of the Ngoni warrior up-close battles when the smell of your enemy lingers with you for as long as you lick your wounds or bask in triumph. With technology, you can kill with precision from 45,000 feet up above the skies - in the comfort of a Nintendo-like console.

Likewise with political communication. Technology has made public discourse so impersonal that you can now manage to debate, to offend, to dazzle or make a fool of yourself all in 140 characters – all from the comfort of your bedroom, boardroom, or even bathroom.

Here I am talking about Twitter, a powerful social media platform which no politician worth his or her salt can ignore. Presidents, Kings, Prime Ministers, celebrities and all sorts of journeymen are on it. Twitter has been so lionized lately to a point of suggestion that it facilitates revolutions.

In Tanzania, in recent years, and within a small but important circle of individuals, it has spiced up and opened a new venue for public discourse. But that has not come without pain and pleasure and without annoyance and great rewards.

I joined Twitter reluctantly after a good friend of mine - @chiume - decided to open an account for me in September 2010. And my handle is a safe and uncreative @JMakamba. Also, another good friend of mine - @zittokabwe – who is also a Member of Parliament and who has been active on Twitter for a while, inspired me. Before then, I was a Facebook boy and had figured that nothing could beat the illusory psychotherapy and awesome voyeurism in the Facebook prompt: “What’s on your mind?’

But I was wrong. Twitter proved to be a big hit for me for its sheer power of compelling you to reveal who you really are – no matter how long you try to pretend. It forces slips into honesty and true identity. My experience on twitter has been quite good. As a public figure, you will necessarily have a lot of people who want to hear what you have to say. Questions come in rapid fire - and on matters public and personal. Some with presumptions and insults, some with sincere desire for information and insight. I have learnt the hard way to treat all questions with the presumption of sincerity. I haven’t always been successful. The good thing about Twitter is that it empowers people on it to directly confront their politicians with their questions and ideas without the protocols and formalities. Some have abused this access but to a large extent twitter engagements are civil.

As a politician, you learn to accept and deal with both blame and praise, with ridicule and adoration – it comes with the territory. Because of impersonal nature of social media, questions and confrontations on twitter can be quite bold, visceral, unreasonable and irritating. I have seen colleagues in politics lose their cool on twitter upon provocation. I also have had to tell one gentleman to “get a life” after making a whole lot of meal out of lack of a certain information he thought should have been in the CCM website. One thing is certain on Twitter debates: you cannot win an argument there. And you must not attempt to. You debate on Twitter not with the view of changing someone’s mind but to state and put your views on record.

As a public personality, people read your words carefully. And mainstream press has in recent days been digging for news and quotes from Twitter and Facebook feeds. It places a huge burden to be forced to be always serious and careful on such an informal platform. But somehow Twitter offers this sense of security that it is alright to be frivolous at times, to be emotional in public, and that you must not always take yourself too seriously.

Some of us in politics have massive egos, and flashes of those can be evident on Twitter. You somehow expect those you follow to follow you back. In some cases, that doesn't happen. Depending on the size of your ego, you may take offense. I've learnt not to - and even not to ask for a follow back.

Civil society activists and entertainment industry people dominate twitter in Tanzania – not necessarily by their numbers but by the frequency and intensity of their tweets. As a Tanzanian politician on Twitter, you are more likely to be engaged by civil society activists. In many cases, they will not be asking questions but will be telling you what you should be doing or what is important or how bad things in the country are or, on occasion, peddling the latest negative report on whatever issue they are working on. That is understandable as the “industry” survives on a negative tone.

In general, Twitter can be like a family – and there are a variations of names to affirm this: twifam, twam, twitfam, etc. You start your day with an understanding of the moods of those you follow. You know people without really knowing them. Much as you may resist, you feel obliged to share news – good or bad, to offer sympathy, and to rejoice in the success of others. You witness fights and take sides – even quietly. You search for encryption keys to cryptic tweets. And you become nosy, digging up threads of conversations that have nothing to do with you. And you rejoice in a retweet as if it is an affirmation of your wit or wisdom.

Twitter has also been a good source of news and information for me. Somehow someone on twitter has updates on happenings around town: be it traffic updates, Dar floods, fuel crisis and so forth. And, depending on who or what you follow, you can get a very good aggregate of all news you need – sometimes as they break. I am personally interested in economic development issues and follow a lot of development people and organizations – and, from twitter, everyday I read some interesting reports, updates and news on development issues.

Twitter can also be a place to make real-life connections with people, create friendships and work for common objectives. I have met a lot of interesting people whom we have made connections through twitter. Few highlights includes during my recent trip to India when I tweeted Shashi Tharoor - @shashitharoor – former United Nations Assistant Secretary General, candidate for UN Secretary General post, and currently India’s foremost intellectual and Member of Parliament, and managed to meet and have a good long chat about global politics and development. I also tracked down my old friend Uhuru Kenyatta - @UKenyatta – Kenya’s Finance Minister and Deputy Prime Minister and had breakfast with him in Kampala early this year because he tweeted that he will be there. Through twitter, I got an intern, Economic Development student from Stanford University in California USA, who did fantastic work with the Bumbuli Development Corporation (BDC) last summer. Through twitter, I hired a PA and Administrator for BDC. I have managed to meet so many different people through Twitter and collaborate in undertaking worthy endeavours.

In the end, twitter, just like any other social media, is just a platform. The key is content. We must not celebrate politicians just for being on it – as is often the case – but for how they use it, and how and what they communicate. If you just come on Twitter to post links to your statements on your website, as one politician I know, then just don’t be on it at all. Twitter certainly doesn’t work as a propaganda platform as most people on it are somehow immune to propaganda.

One of the weaknesses of some of us in politics is that we always calculate and peg our actions in terms of votes and elections. Surely, if I am to run again for MP for Bumbuli, I will not be reelected because I am on Twitter or because of things I say on it. And most of my constituents, with almost zero access to the internet, are not on twitter. So, in terms of electoral calculus, I shouldn’t be on Twitter. But I have made a decision that I cannot afford to miss the opportunity to be intellectually challenged, to be quizzed, to be informed, to be annoyed, and to understand the psyche of the urbane and sophisticated segment of Tanzanians who are on Twitter. And I cannot afford to miss the chance to engage the global citizenry that follow Tanzania.

Moral of the story: tweet!
-----------------------------------------------------------------

January Makamba is a Member of Parliament for Bumbuli constituency, Chairman of the Parliamentary Committee on Energy and Minerals, and CCM Secretary for Political Affairs and International Relations. He tweets using @JMakamba.

Monday, November 14, 2011

Time for a Technocrat President in Tanzania?

We have tried a middle of the road type of a socialism that never truly worked. Behind it was an exemplary idealist and once in a generation leader in Mwalimu. Four years into his retirement, Berlin Wall fell; with it, 31 years of socio-economic experiment came to an end—with mixed results. Tanzania is a unified republic with a clear national identity; albeit with unperfected union. At 50 years old, Tanzania’s potential for human development is yet to be realized, the increasing income inequality (the fallacy of 7% growth) is squandering away the social capital that Mwalimu and Mzee Mwinyi had accrued. It has yet been clear to our governments that embracing untamed and imported neoliberal economic policies will not only wreck havoc to our fortunes, but also threatening our social fabric. The 2008 financial crisis was largely caused by income inequality*. Nevertheless, previous Tanzania’s government embraced the market economy wholeheartedly, though in some cases it was imposed upon us. If 17% of your budget is beyond your means, there goes your sovereignty—on everything. But I will argue that our embracing of bad economic policies is mainly caused by a misinformed leadership at helm more than anything.

For starters, our government is a massive, slow bureaucracy that is also inefficient. As it is, our government incentivizes her inefficiency—which sustains the crisis. The longer it takes for your passport to be issued, increases your likeliness to bribe. Why should the passport manager hurry up to issue you a passport? This is the model of our government from bottom-up. Its pretty shitty. No private company would be able to survive under this model. Too bad citizens are not allowed to shop for governments of their residence. That would be the perfect market solution to punish our lousy governments. Surprisingly, national dialogue on development continues to bypass the fundamental flaw of our country, an ancient governing model. As I pointed earlier, this too is the leadership problem.

Tanzanians have always elected career politicians for the presidency. Mzee Mwinyi, Mzee Mkapa, and currently Jakaya Kikwete were all career politicians prior to the presidency. Even opposition parties also nominated career politicians. Dr. Slaa is the embodiment of a career politician, so as Prof Lipumba (by virtue of running more than twice). Folks who after decades of running sections of the inefficient bureaucracy have convinced themselves that, only they have the wisdom to take us to the promise land. But they almost always underperform. To me, this is a manifestation of their lack of policy knowledge, and lack of understanding of intricate ways of the barbarous globalized economy. I am not saying wonkish president will save us, few politicians are wonkier than Bill Clinton and yet he repealed Glass-Steagall Act . I am saying that, the next election might be the appropriate time to elect wonkish president, because for our government to work for the people, it needs a leader who has intimate knowledge of how to reform a demented institution with 6 billion dollars budget. Career politicians do not possess such knowledge. More than anything, he will increase the size of it all to accommodate all his political allies he accumulated over the years. In Italy and Greece, career politicians have all retired leaving the position for more technocratic Prime Ministers. The ground is shifting beneath us.

The next presidential election in Tanzania, might be of the most important for this generation. We still have our social fabric intact, which is vastly needed for any growth; but we do not know how long this fabric will remain intact—with the increasing income inequality**. We will need the president who can best articulate the policy prescription to our government so that she can live within her means, while also protecting the society from the externalities generated by our investors. We ought to look for the leader who can dare to create an income inequality that would benefit the poorest, bridging the technological gap, and reform our rather messed up education system. To get that kind of a leader will require political parties to nominate for more technocrat candidates and shy away from the good ole names that we have been used to hear for decades.

*****


* Stagnant incomes of Americans, made subprime mortgage a trillion dollar industry. Basically, a trillion dollar of garbage loans that did not qualify for government backed security.

**Arab awakening is the results of income inequality that is threatening social fabrics of these countries. Tanzania can be next.

Tuesday, November 1, 2011

The Flexibility of Bongo Flava!

Dushelele and Hakunaga are equally catchy songs and are destroying competition in Dar as we are speaking. I don't know about The Runway crowd, but when these two songs are blasted in Masai Club Kinondoni or Billicanas, the crowd goes nuts. Yaani usipime kabisa. However, none of these two songs are originally Tanzanian sound. Suma Lee in Hakunaga is playing into the resurgence of Kwaito music in Bongo, and the whole Shafo dancing style. Ali Kiba with ManWalter are more chaneling our obsession with that Congolese Sound. I am not sure if there is originality in Bongo Flavas anymore, but these two songs in a right atmosphere are ridiculously entertaining.

Dushele-Ali Kiba


Hakunaga-Suma Lee



Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Recollecting New Orleans

It’s a laid back place; there is casual sense of urgency. The air is thick, and the sun is shining throughout the year. Her indignant are a unique alloy of diverse pool of people. They have all kinds of blood. There is sound of music everywhere, everyday, all the time. Music leaves here; you will find children moving around with their textbook bags and trumpets on their hands. There is always a distinct sound that follows you everywhere you go. For those who come to visit, you can call them tourists; this is a carefree environment. Where folks choose to retire their orderliness and pursue a lifestyle free of constraints. Liberty at its purest form resides in New Orleans. For those who reside here, this is their way of life.

People here do not need reasons to celebrate. The biggest Halloween party I have ever been stretches over 6 blocks of Frenchmenn Street packed with people on all kinds of costumes. The party will go on all night. On Mexican Independence Day, St. Charles Ave & Antoine Street shuts down and folks party up more than those in Mexico City. There is a weekend of French Quarter Festival which is one of my favorite; live music, good food, and booze at the bank of Mississippi river on the edges of The Quarters. Every Wednesday evening at Lafayette square, locals get a treat of live music and good food—and there is no cover charge. Just show up. St. Patrick’s Day brings out a little Irish in everybody. Although the city is known for its major events like Mardi Grass and Jazz Festival, there are small festivals which take place throughout the year that are equally entertaining. With a little encroachment from those tourists.

You see, you can catch good music at Soul Rebel in Magazine Street, maybe random concert at Tipitina any day of the week. Speaking of Magazine Street, although upscale-ish it resides most comprehensives restaurant and booze joints in the city. Wide selections of beer at The Bulldog, drunken- greasy food at Balcony Bar, and maybe random chilling/sport bars of Rendezvous and Tracies. You can't go wrong with Rum House's Tacos; But the true gem in Magazine Street is The Bridge’s Lounge. A hipster place which also hosts a variety of good music and a diverse crowd of young urbanites. Heading downtown, in central business district and lower garden district are few gems worthy exploring. Many bars in this area are full of Abercrombie & Fitch crowd. The Fraternity crowd extends from The Republic, RedEye, and Lucys. But one joint stands out from the fraternity crowd, 12 Bar on Fulton has been one of my favorite in central business—also Whisky Blue at The W lounge, and LePhare on Gravier St have always been a perfect pre-game pubs.

Mid-City is rather quiet and more residential, but don’t get it twisted. Best fried chicken in the world is at Ms Willie Mae’s restaurant, while best Po-Boys in town are at Parkway Bakery; both located in Mid-City. The best brass band experience in the city is at Candlelight, also in Mid-City, coming with complimentary NOLA’s signature red beans and rice. Every Wednesday night candlelight is lively with brass band music, and you can swiftly transition to Dragons Den’s to cap the night in a reggae club with DJ T.Roy. Mid-city also host the iconic Finns McCool pub, here is where you can catch a live Arsenal game—sipping a fresh Guinness at 9 am. That is how many Saturdays usually start. And Arsenal disappoints most of the time.

The quarters are fun and always crowded, Bourbon being Bourbon, is the epitome of it all. Not being the biggest fan of the quarters, but it remains the center of entertainment in New Orleans. Best brunch joint on weekends at Café Amelie on Royal Street. Probably the best street in the Quarter is Royal, with its mix of residential/restaurant/artistry stores. I caught The Wailers at the legendary House of Blues on Decatur Street. Stretching the Quarters further, you will find Frenchmenn Street, which is always musical. You can catch Little Fred King live at DBA, Brass-A-Hollic at Maison, and a Mannie Fresh concert at Maison’s penthouse. Frenchmenn also host reggae nights on Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday at Dragons Den, Blue Nile, and Café Negril respectively. A very old form of European Jazz and blues is at display at The Spotted Cat, while in Frenchmenn Street, Vaso is always worthy of exploration. You can show up to Frenchmenn at 2 am in Tuesday morning, and you will have fun. Stretching further away from Frenchmenn is Marigny area—and there is Mimis pub located in this part of NOLA. Saturdays night is full of 70s and 80s funk music under the watchful eye of Dj Soul Sista. The Orange Couch coffee shop is also located in this area. Whenever you are in need of a quiet work time, this is the ultimate coffee shop to get work done.

The city is not the same, compared to its pre-Katrina days, but it is definitely not dead. As the matter of fact, very few folks in the city talk about Katrina anymore. Although the population has vastly decreased and low income communities are pushed away from their housings near city center. The City continues to be a distinct place and there is no place like New Orleans. My most memorable NOLA moment began when The Saints won Super Bowl, followed by Saints parade, and Mardi Grass shortly followed; it was crazy!

Thursday, September 15, 2011

Remarks by January Makamba at CEO Roundtable Dinner - 13 September, 2011

Remarks by January Makamba at CEO Roundtable Dinner - 13 September, 2011

Friends, Ladies and Gentlemen,

I would like to thank the membership of CEO Roundtable for your kind invitation to join you for this dinner and speak before you.

I thank you Ali – for your stewardship of this important forum, and as one of thought leaders in business and society.

You have asked me to speak on two very important issues. Electricity and Fuel. These two issues are complex and multifaceted – and greatly implicate the wellbeing of our country.

It is therefore always a challenge, given the time we have, to exhaust all facets of any of these issues, let alone all. So, I will focus on just a few dimensions that are relevant to as many of us as possible.

I will spend more time on energy – as I know that is of particular interest to most of you. And in this respect I would like to recognise your statement made in July, which not only delivered concrete ideas on how to deal with the crisis but also improved the quality of the energy debate – quality which hitherto had been so wanting.

I would hope that these kinds of dialogue – between government and private sector, between Members of Parliament and business community will continue – as we strive to make our country better.

First, what is the situation now? I don’t need to tell you this, but for many years now, the electricity that is generated has not been meeting the demand. In addition, we have not been able to ascertain and plan for the actual demand for power in this country. Still, not being able to meet the demand for only 14 percent of households, for these many years, speaks for the challenge we have in the sector. Anyway, this is another debate, but if we are talking about power shortage as a crisis, then we have really been in a permanent crisis.

According to the Energy Minister’s report in Parliament last month, the installed generation capacity in the country is 1,102MW. For a country of 43 million people, this is a very small amount. As of last month, according to the same report, production at all sources was 623MW. Therefore, as we speak, 479MW that we previously had in the grid is now off grid. This is about 40 percent of the capacity. The current crisis is deeper perhaps because this is a record amount of power to go off the grid. For there to be no load-shedding, we need to add at least 300MW back to the grid.

You obviously have read about what transpired in Parliament last month that led to the initiation of the current emergency measures to deal with the current crisis. My assessment of the plan here tonight is with clear understanding that some of the measures promised are ongoing, but also I recognize that there were milestones to be met before December, including statements made by the Minister last week that there will be movements and relief this week, relief that has so far not materialized. And indeed some of us are duty bound to speak up when we see the public losing trust and confidence in public officials.

So, what entails in the current Emergency Plan?

In short, there are two phases of the Plan. First phase: between July – December, where a total of 572MW is aimed to be added into the grid through additional generation from existing Symbion (37MW) and IPTL (80MW) plants, and introduction of 100MW from Aggreko, 205MW from new Symbion contract, 150MW from NSSF.

Aiming to add 572MW in a matter of four months is quite bold and ambitious. I was excited when it was presented in the Parliament because this kind of ambition and boldness is what I have been calling for. But I was – and I remain – cautiously optimistic. We have seen many broken promises before, most recently the one to generate 260MW by July – a plan that was approved in the cabinet in February but has not materialized up to today.

Nevertheless, we know that the 37MW Symbion generation will be done. We know that Aggreko is already here – because they started the process early during the year (although they were supposed to deliver on August 15). And we all know the story of IPTL – running out of fuel every so often. So, what we are guaranteed by December is at least 137MW.

The 205MW from Symbion is still a “story” as contract has not been signed yet as we speak. Story goes that it is at EWURA waiting for approval. And here lies another question: as a regulator of utility, at what point exactly does EWURA supposed to be involved in power projects? From contract negotiations – as an enforcer of good contracts? Or, during tariff application process – as an enforcer of tariff generated from “prudently incurred costs”? So, while people in government are mentioning Symbion as a solution, Symbion has not yet shipped the plant because I don’t think any businessman would mobilize a $300m equipment without a contract. I still retain confidence that this, in the end, will be done – not so much as a result of urgency in the government bureaucracy, but for the sheer persistence and need for certainty from equipment supplier and contractor.

The 150MW from NSSF – I know I will be unpopular for saying this: but you can forget about it, at least during this year. They promised to deliver 150MW by December with foggy idea of where they are going to get the plant, and where in Dar es Salaam they are going to install it. They relied on word from people who didn’t have even offices, and I heard that a team of 9 people from NSSF and other government institutions went to the United States (why 9 people? I really don’t know) and found nothing. Now, there is yet another word that there is a plant in France – and a team of people is going there again tomorrow to have a look – and do “due diligence”. But this Paris plant is, first, of less than 150MW and, secondly, of Frame Six type – which is technically complex and takes minimally eight months to install. So, it will not be here before Christmas – if in fact that is what they choose to go with. In any case, one expects that NSSF, as a public institution, will procure this plant through a tender process, which again complicates the matter.

So, again this is phase one of emergency plan. What is the cost? 523 billion shillings. What will be TANESCO’s revenues? 115 billion. Deficit: 408 billion. How will it be funded? Through commercial loans. But who will be willing to lend money to TANESCO? None that I know. Therefore, we will most certainly rely on a government guarantee. Now, we just have to be honest with ourselves. This is not just a loan guarantee for TANESCO. This is straight loan to the government. And it will be serviced through taxpayers’ money. And there is an injustice here. 86 percent of households do not have electricity, but through the taxes they also pay, they are in effect subsidizing those 14 percent of us who enjoy it.

Another feature of the financing of this plan is that the payments will be in foreign currency. Power producers are paid in foreign currency and fuel to run these generators are imported by foreign currency. Given the magnitude of the payment – if you add phase two of the Plan, which comes to 1.2 trillion shillings – the plan will have implications on balance of payment, foreign currency reserves and strength of the shilling. So, measures will have to be taken so that these expensive emergency power plans do not come at the expense of the stability of the economy.

For the Second Phase of Emergency Plan – running from January to December 2012, there are three projects, which will aim to bring additional 460MW into the grid. Jacobsen Gas Plant in Ubungo, Semco HFO Plant in Nyakato Mwanza, and another Jacobsen Plant of 150MW in Dar es Salaam as well. The interesting thing about these projects is that the first two were supposed to be finished this year – but they are now termed as emergency plans for next year.

And secondly, there are serious issues of fuel to run these plants. As it is today, there is no enough gas to run the existing gas plants. The earliest time that you can deliver gas to Dar, given the existing gas infrastructure upgrade plans, will be the first quarter of 2013. So, in essence, you will have 250MW of plants sitting idle as white elephants.

I think that it is scandalous to have ordered this Jacobsen gas plant for $124m almost two years ago, and not plan for the gas to run it. There is a talk that once it arrives, the gas currently used by Symbion to produce 75MW will be diverted to this plant and Symbion will run on Jet A1. That is fine, but it does not, and should not, absolve some people at TANESCO and the Ministry for poor planning – and compelling the nation into an expensive proposition.

Of course, they may have ordered dual-fuel plants – meaning that they can fire them using liquid fuel as well as gas. But, if you consider that the entire 572MW of generation between now and December is supposed to use expensive imported liquid fuels, this will mean for more than a year, our country will be generating a total of 1,032MW using imported liquid fuels. This is next to impossible to sustain.
To conclude on the emergency plans, my general view about the emergency plans is that while they are necessary at times, they cannot be something we resort to every time. You can’t be in an emergency for five years – as five years is enough time to sort out a permanent solution. Emergency power should be a bridging power, a temporary solution to give you space to find a permanent solution. My hope, which I expressed in the Parliament, is that this will be the last emergency plan.

And ideas on permanent solutions are plenty. This is a country blessed with almost all sources of energy in plentiful: gas, coal, hydro sources, wind, solar, and geothermal. It is scandalous for a country such as ours to generate grid electricity using expensive imported liquid fuels. The question to ask is why, for instance, we don’t have a single coal plant despite massive amounts of coal in the country. I am sure you have read about these many plans, some in the books since 1980s. I do not intend to review them here.

But I want to say that the main issue is planning. In energy, nothing is more important than planning. And, in energy planning, 10 years is short term. I just hope that our planners have thoroughly thought beyond December 2012, and 2014 when some of these rental contracts will expire and generation will go off the grid.

So, what do I propose as way forward?


1. Sort out TANESCO –


For better or for worse, TANESCO sits squarely at the centre of energy problems or solutions in this country. It is a massive utility that is very impressive on paper. Last year, it booked 500bn revenue. It has operating capital of more than $1bn, and assets worth more than a couple of billion dollars. And it has the capacity to triple its revenue and assets in just five years. Few companies in Tanzania, both private and public, can match these numbers. But TANESCO is not performing as it should – constantly in the red, and having to be subsidised by government. In many other countries, utility companies are blue chips – whose stocks are hot. I remain confident that TANESCO can be the same.

If we can transform TANESCO to what it can be, we may start to see light at the end of the tunnel. But the government will have to figure out what it wants to do with TANESCO. All of us can help to put pressure for the right structure and role for TANESCO.

There have been so many ideas – and so many studies - about the right structure and role for TANESCO. The most popular one is splitting it into three functional and business units.

But the question is: split it and then what? Do you split it but still keep the units in government hands? Or do you privatise all the units or not? Perhaps only one or two? And if so, which ones exactly?

I am in favour of the Kenyan model. TANESCO has too many functions. It generates power, it runs the grid, buys power from IPPs, it owns and operates transmission and distribution system, and it supplies electricity. These are complex functions for one organisation at this point in time. And with the law permitting IPPs and competition in the industry, one can conclude that there is anti-competition environment in the industry. TANESCO should not be negotiating tenders with firms it is by law supposed to compete with – and may one day compete with.

Henceforth, I would say split TANESCO into three functional and business units and issue IPOs for its units. I can guarantee that they will be oversubscribed and you will get all the money you need to invest in energy. Transmission unit will have to be largely owned by government initially – given the big differential between investment and margins. Of course, this is not panacea because the principles of running a business will still have to be adhered to whether you have one or three units, or whether it is a publicly traded company or a parastatal. But at least you will guarantee focus on each business and functional unit. You will also guarantee pressure from shareholders for transparency, better management, better business decisions and accountability for failure – critical elements that are missing at the moment in TANESCO.

In the end, the maturity of business culture and environment will be critical in the success of this idea. The quality of service of each unit will depend on the efficiency of the other unit. Therefore, there ought to exist commercial discipline that ensures that all three units of the industry – generation, distribution and transmission – are legally bound to honour their obligations to each other. The beauty though is that once you get to a level where you have multiple firms in each unit, competition for high performance will arise and end-users will be able to choose who to do business with.

In the meantime, as it is today, TANESCO can and should be able to make sound business and management decisions – only if politicians stop to be its manager and spokesperson.

A lot of us – and even TANESCO – has been talking a lot about putting new power plants to ease the crisis. But electricity is beyond generators. What about repairing transmission and distribution systems that are currently not in good shape?

For instance, last year alone, mainly because of poor transmission and distribution infrastructure, TANESCO lost 21 percent of power it produced and/or bought. This lost electricity amounted to more than 1,200 GWhr – which is more than all electricity used in factories and businessplaces for the entire year, and amounted to about 75 percent of all electricity bought from Songas in the entire year. These are massive losses – which, if curbed, in themselves would have helped with the power situation. But TANESCO will need to invest in Repair and Maintenance for this to be possible. And we know that this is not happening. While it is required by best [utility] industry practice to spend 12 percent of revenue on Repair and Maintenance, TANESCO spent only 2.8 percent of its revenue on R and M between 2005-2008 – and result is lots of broken transformers and service lines and a huge amount of lost electricity.

2. Make it easy for private investment in energy sector

One of the things I hear the most when I talk to businesspeople is how difficult it is to do business in Tanzania – particularly to invest in energy sector. I am told of people who had come here keen on investing on energy but simply could not bear the red tape and the uncertainty. But what I don’t understand is why and how we make it so difficult for people to come in and invest in a sector we so desperately need. The last non-rental private investment in energy in Tanzania was in 2004 – seven years ago. And the last three plants to be built in Tanzania were by the government.
Now, if electricity generation pays – both for private investors and for TANESCO – as it surely does when gas is the fuel, why should the government spend billions of shillings in taxpayer’s money to buy generators?

As it is now, there is no power investment guideline – both in terms of process and basis for PPA negotiations – for investors to rely on. Energy deals are structured so differently depending on how desperate the energy situation is at the time, and permits and approvals depends on the depth of your contacts and the kind of pressure or incentives you are able to put.

This must change. Power projects are complex. Private investors commit a big number of people – some up to 30, lawyers and financial people and so on – in a single project just to get the project to take off. And over here, you have few people who are so scattered across government – TIC, BRELA, NEMC, TRA, EWURA, TANESCO, and Ministry of Energy – and who have so many other things to deal with such that these projects do not receive the needed attention.

I believe that planning and overseeing fast execution of power projects should be coordinated at the very top level of leadership of the country, with absolutely no tolerance for delays and excuses. In Nigeria, President Goodluck Jonathan has formed, and chairs, the Presidential Action Committee on Power (PACP) which consists of Ministers and Heads of Agencies that have a critical role to play in Nigeria’s power sector. It acts like a “War Cabinet” for Nigeria’s power sector, setting policy and granting expedited approvals for critical decisions. The PACP meets every Tuesday, yes, every week! This ensures that issues connected to the power sector enjoy priority attention at the highest level of government. I think we ought to do something like that here given the gravity of the situation – and importance of energy to the economy.

3. Sort out gas issue

Gas, which we have plenty of – and plenty more onshore for the future, is critical for the permanent solution to the power crisis.
So, it is critically important that we sort the fuel question. Why? Because, even if you are able to airlift a 300MW gas power plant to Dar today, you will get Zero power as there is simply no gas. It is not that there isn’t enough natural gas in the country. It is just that we haven’t planned well to extract and get it to where the generators are at critical moment.

As it is today, in this coming year, we will produce more power from very expensive imported fuel than from cheap gas which we already have in the country.
If you consider when gas was discovered and wells we dug in Songosongo, we are 20 years behind in gas utilisation. If we had planned better in terms of gas infrastructure, today 70 percent of our power generation would have been coming from gas. Given the desperate situation we are in today, everyone is talking about gas infrastructure project or a gas power plant. This is good but it requires better planning and coordination. There ought to be coordination on who is doing what and when, and at the same time analysing the implications of all these efforts on price and availability of power. A Gas Master Plan is badly needed.

4. Sort out tariff issue

We seriously need to look at the electricity tariff structure. No doubt that TANESCO could do better to manage its cost of service. But we need to decide in this country whether electricity is a business or a subsidized service. The current tariff is not commercially viable. The government recognizes that the current tariff does not work. That is the reason it is subsidizing to the tune of 5bn shillings per year a private company in Mtwara to sell electricity at a price equal to TANESCO’s.

Not only does the current tariff hurt TANESCO’s balance sheet and its repair and maintenance capabilities, it also discourages private investment in energy sector, particularly in alternative energy. For instance, for solar generation to be commercially viable, the tariff has to be in the upwards of 20 cents (mostly because of the heavy initial investment).

Some may say that it is impossible for the majority of people to afford higher tariff. I don’t believe so. Look at how much Tanzanians are spending on phone airtime. The current tariff structure is such that TANESCO sells power at the more or less the same rate to end-users, regardless of whether it is to a barber shop in Namanga or to a Barrick Gold Mine in North Mara. The tariff should be dynamic and flexible given the volatility in the fuel prices and different capacities of TANESCO customers. There are those who will be willing to pay higher tariff as long as power is steady and reliable. For instance, with industries, power, even at higher price, features insignificantly to the cost of production; but when it is NOT available it is a very significant contribution to losses.

4. Coal, Wind, Solar and Geothermal

Ambition and innovation can – and should – be brought to fore to exploit the four critical sources of energy (coal, wind, solar, and geothermal) that we have in plenty, and which other countries are producing huge amounts of electricity from. There is absolutely no excuse that, as it stands today, all these sources – cheap and plentiful – are not being used to produce electricity.

Coal powered industrial revolution in many developed countries. We have it in plenty – in Ngaka, Mchuchuma, Kiwira and other places. Coal is so cheap that, even if you ferry it in ships from South Africa to generate electricity in Dar es Salaam, that electricity may still be cheaper than the one we are going to produce using diesel.

I am happy that at least there are two companies in Tanzania exploring the possibility of producing electricity through wind. We need to move fast the approval processes.

On solar, few companies have come in to express interest in putting up solar farms – and produce up to 300MW. The issue, of course, with renewable has always been the high tariff. But one company that has such big solar projects in different parts of the world presented a proposal to sell solar power to TANESCO at 25 cents per KW. But we said it is too expensive – which is true because TANESCO sells power at about 10 cents. But then again, we are now buying power from some companies at about 37 cents, power generated from fuels which we import through foreign currency!

Geothermal energy is generated from steam resulting from underground volcanic activity – steam that run turbines to produce power. Many countries with underground volcanic fields – Iceland being the leading one – are producing electricity. Kenya is. There is no reason we shouldn’t. We have more volcanic fields, the Rift Valley, a case in point – and therefore higher potential – than Kenya, but Kenya decided that, by 2018, 50 percent of its electricity will be produced through geothermal. And 25 percent of this year’s Kenya’s energy budget has been set for development of geothermal power. Of course there is a huge initial cost of exploration of fields that discourages the private sector investment. What Kenya has done, and what we ought to do, is establish geothermal authority, in which government funds exploration, and put proven fields to tender. The outcome is that those who win tender even reimburse the government for exploration costs. This we must do.

I want to end up here on energy issue, as there are simply too many things to talk about – things that we may take up as we interact later.

Fuel Crisis:

Very briefly on fuel crisis: The nation almost went to a standstill weeks ago when a new price announcement by EWURA resulted into protest by OMCs. It was embarrassing both for the government and for EWURA, causing great inconvenience to the people and businesses. This is what I know:

1. In a new indicative price formula that EWURA used, the platts (base) price for diesel that EWURA used was for a cheaper, high-in-sulphur diesel type that we don’t import anymore (5000ppm). So, that led to an arrival in lower indicative price.

2. The exchange rate that EWURA used was BOT’s with a margin of 20-25 shillings against the actual rate used by importers.

3. We know that ships waits for an average of 30 days to offload fuel at the port – and each day a ship is charged $20,000 – $22,000, and these charges are reflected in the cost of fuel import, and eventually pump price. But EWURA provisioned for 3 days at a cost of $18,000 per day – something against reality.

4. On wharfage (port) cost on diesel, EWURA’s indicative price formula put it at $7 per metric ton, while Tanzania Port Authority charges at $10.4 per metric ton. In Mombasa and Beira, the same is charged at $3 per metric ton. More interestingly, fuel for neighbouring countries that passes through the port of Dar is charged at $3 per metric ton. Now, why would you charge your people $10.4 while neighbours who don’t have ports charge $3? And why would EWURA put wharfage at $7 while it is clear that importers are charged at $10?

5. Then there is an issue of conversion from metric tonnes (used for importation) to litres (used for setting indicative price). The conversion was not realistic.

6. Also, again on exchange rate: the basis that EWURA uses is the rate of first day of the following 14 days that the indicative price is applicable. This would have been okay if fuel importers were paying cash. But we know that most of importers import on credit, and also do not finish their stock in 14 days, and so when the shilling is falling it implicates on their margins.

7. Now, we know that EWURA has been issuing indicative prices since January 2009, and there hasn’t been a crisis like this one despite some of these imperfections. This is because some of these imperfections were taken care by a cushion of 7.5% that EWURA had been featuring in the pricing formula. But EWURA immediately removed it – saying that importers are making too much money.

And then there is a folly of EWURA suspending BP, a company which government has 50 percent stake in. Now, if you could not force a company you partly own – and which you have access to all its books and costs – to abide to your new price, then something must be very wrong. The result of BP suspension is that you also share the loss as a shareholder; and as a big importer TRA suffers in revenues.

A debate in necessity for price setting is one we should have. More importantly, I would think that the relationship, the understanding and communication between the regulator and regulated entities is very critical in the functioning of the industry. There is absolutely no need for public fights and show of machismo. And there is absolutely no need to sow divisions among oil importers and treat them differently and isolate others so that industry regulation can prevail.

So, as Government you can force oil companies to sell fuels at the pumps and deliver it from depots – since you control instruments of order. But you can’t force an importer to place an order from the refineries overseas. From what I hear, and I hope it is not true, some companies have reduced their fuel orders to Tanzania, and some have turned around ships that were heading this way.

The biggest impact of the crisis was not just that weeklong of inconvenience – but the deterioration of confidence in EWURA as a regulator, and more so on Tanzania as a market and reliable place to do business.

In concluding

Finally, I would like to challenge you to look at the power situation in Tanzania from a different perspective. I think most in business community have looked at it as constant bottleneck to business progress – and rightly so. But we need to broaden that outlook. With our economic growth expected to hit double digits within this decade, infrastructure investment, especially in power, is obviously the next big thing. Seven years from now, conservative estimates show that Tanzania power demands will hit around 10,000 GWh, and triple that by 2030 at 30,000 GWh. Within the next 20 years, the power sector will attract investments of well over $30 billion. Generation costs per kWh are projected to drop substantially to 10 cents from current 15.3 cents, and still by 2020, revenues to power providers are expected to hit $3 billion annually, while their expenditure around $2 billion. At current values of power to the economy, the power sector will contribute well over $11 billion to our national GDP by 2030.

This opens up an array of extraordinarily impressive business opportunities for you. And it will be a shame if you stay on the sidelines.

Time is now.

I thank you for your kind attention!

Monday, September 12, 2011

What is Holding Africa from Prosperity?

The late Prof Abdulrahman Mohamed Babu had pointed out these facts in his important book, An Economic Strategy for the Second Liberation of Africa (1994).

1. Dependence on the developed world for Africa’s own development

2. Excessive use of socially necessary labor time in the production of useless goods for export, instead of useful goods for our own human development

3. Unequal trade terms, about which, position of economic weakness arise from export of primary commodities only.

4. Unproductive use of the foreign debts incurred (and the corruption that goes with it), and debt service obligations at extremely unjustified high cost

5. Poor energy policies that make us heavily dependent on external sources of energy and the depletion of our meager foreign exchange earnings in paying for the rising cost of oil imports

6. An irrational world economic order as a whole which, again cannot be changed from a position of economic weakness.


U